New York-style Pizza

new york style pizza

After the New York City pizza bit on “The Daily Show” aired about a week ago, I could’t get those glorious pies out of my head. While those of us in the gluten-free crowd likely won’t be able to enjoy a slice at the various restaurants mentioned by Mr. Stewart, there’s no need to feel deprived — you can make your own New York-style pizza at home!

This is a really fun dough to work with; it’s quite stretchy (not as much as gluten doughs, so I advise avoiding any fancy tossing moves), not too sticky (meaning that it rolls out nicely without the addition of a lot of extra flour), and the olive oil helps make your hands softer than before (one of the few times that cooking actually directly benefits your skin). I love that this dough keeps well stored in the fridge — after rising for two hours at room temp or an overnight refrigerator rise — for about three days. (Typically, I make a double batch so I can throw together pizzas during the week in a flash. Bring dough to room temp before using.)

perfection: blistery bottom, gooey cheese

With a very simple sheet pan setup (described in the recipe), you can even achieve the blistery bottom usually only found on pizzeria pizzas. As such, your slices will have the perfectly crisp bottom layer and slightly more doughy layer combo that is characteristic of New York-style pizza. Just remember, don’t stack your slices (the steam!) and no forks allowed (you fold it, then you eat it). Mangia bene!

New York-Style Pizza

Active Preparation Time: 30 – 45 minutes

Inactive Preparation Time: 2 hours, minimum

Serves: 4-6


Pizza Sauce:

  • 28 ounce can Whole Tomatoes
  • 1 tablespoon (14 grams) Garlic, minced
  • 1 tablespoon (14 grams) Olive Oil
  • 1/4 – 1/2 teaspoon Red Pepper Flakes (optional)
  • 1/4 teaspoon Whole Fennel Seed
  • 2 tablespoons Dried Basil, divided
  • 113 grams (1/2 cup) Water
  • Kosher Salt, to taste

Pizza Dough:

  • 120 grams (1 cup) Millet Flour
  • 120 grams (1 cup) Garbanzo Fava Flour
  • 96 grams (1/2 cup) Potato Starch
  • 64 grams (1/2 cup) Arrowroot Starch
  • 5 teaspoons (15 grams) Xanthan Gum
  • 4 teaspoons (13 grams) Bob’s Red Mill Active Dry Yeast
  • 1 teaspoon (4 grams) Kosher Salt
  • 255 grams (9 ounces or 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons) Water
  • 28 grams (4 teaspoons) Agave Nectar or Honey
  • 28 grams (2 tablespoons) Cider Vinegar
  • 57 grams (1/4 cup) Olive Oil, plus more to grease bowl

For Assembling and Serving:

  • Millet Flour, for rolling out dough
  • 16 ounces water-packed, fresh Mozzarella, drain and pat dry, thinly slice large balls (such as Ovolini or Bocconcini) or halve Ciliegini (cherry tomato shape)¹
  • Parmesan Cheese
  • Red Pepper Flakes
  • Dried Oregano


Make Sauce:

Transfer tomatoes and their juices to a 4-cup measuring cup. Using your hands, squeeze tomatoes to quickly and roughly crush them; set aside. Place a sauté pan or 4 quart pot over medium heat. Add garlic through fennel seed to the hot pan and sauté for about 30 seconds to a minute, or just until the garlic begins to turn golden. Add crushed tomatoes, 1 tablespoon of the basil, and the water to the garlic mixture. Bring mixture to a boil, stir well, cover with a splatter screen, and reduce heat to low. Continue to simmer, stirring occasionally, for 2 hours.

After 2 hours, remove pan from heat and allow mixture to cool to room temperature (15 – 30 minutes depending on pan depth). Transfer to a blender (preferably glass) or food processor, add the other tablespoon of dried basil and purée until smooth. Makes about 2 cups sauce.

Make Dough:

In the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, combine millet flour though salt; whisk well to combine. In a spouted measuring cup or bowl, whisk together water through olive oil. With the mixer running on low, pour wet ingredients into flour mixture. Increase speed to medium and mix dough for two minutes. In the meantime, grease a bowl (at least 1 quart) with olive oil; set aside.

Turn dough out onto a clean, lightly greased counter. Coat your hands with olive oil and shape dough into a ball (doesn’t need to be perfect). Place dough into the bowl. Cover top of the bowl with plastic wrap. Allow it to rise for two hours (or until doubled in size) at warm room temperature before assembling pizzas or refrigerating for later use (use within 3 days). Alternatively, you may place the dough in the fridge to rise overnight (use within 3 days).

Assemble and Serve:

Once sauce is made and the dough has risen, remove all but one rack from the oven. Place remaining rack on the lowest level, set a large, rimmed baking sheet upside down on top of it, and preheat to 500° F.

Punch down dough and divide into 8 pieces (about 3.5 ounces each); cover with a barely damp cloth to prevent them from drying out. Roll dough out on a clean, millet flour coated surface into a very thin, about 1/8″ thick, circle. Transfer dough to a sheet of aluminum foil. Top with about 1/4 cup sauce, spread evenly (an offset spatula is useful for this, too), leaving about 1/4″ border around the edges. Top with mozzarella (about 2 ounces) and a sprinkle of Parmesan. Place pizza, aluminum foil and all, onto the hot baking sheet. Bake for 6-8 minutes or until mozzarella is melted and crust is golden brown.

Transfer pizza to a cooling rack for couple minutes before slicing (the cheese is waaaaaay too gooey to slice neatly right away). Serve with additional Parmesan, red pepper flakes and oregano on the side. Repeat with remaining dough.


¹ I prefer using Ciliegini because all of the pieces of mozzarella are the same size, resulting in more even cheese distribution. Plus, it is much easier to cut them in half (using a knife or kitchen shears) than it is to slice the balls. I typically purchase fresh mozzarella at Trader Joe’s; it’s also available at Whole Foods and most grocery store chains.

You Might Also Like


  • Reply
    Holly Henry
    June 9, 2011 at 1:04 pm

    This looks so yummy! I love making home made pizza and will add this to my list. Thanks for sharing!
    Nice blog you have !


    You can visit me @

  • Reply
    heather sage
    June 9, 2011 at 1:09 pm

    thank you, holly!

  • Reply
    Thought picker
    November 24, 2013 at 8:14 pm

    Whats a replacement for garbanzo bean flour? I don’t like the taste.

    • Reply
      Heather Sage
      November 25, 2013 at 3:05 pm

      I’d encourage you to give the garbanzo fava flour (I never use straight garbanzo) a try in this recipe. With the mix of millet and starches its flavor — which I know is horrendous before cooking — is totally unnoticeable; the crust tastes identical to what’s sold at your local pizza parlor!

      As for a sub, I’d recommend your favorite flour that has a similar weight, amount of protein and carbohydrate (30 grams per quarter cup, 6g, 18 g respectively) — that should give you the most similar result.

    Leave a Reply

    This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.